Thursday, 7 January 2010

sciences, methods

Empirical evidence is evidence we have tested by observing something ourself via our senses. As we have seen in the different way we process sensory information, our perception is not always 100% reliable, so a way of testing empirical evidence is provided by following a scientific approach.


This week we have looked at 4 possible approaches to explain the true scientific method.

These are:

Inductivism.
Falsification.
Paradigms.
Anarchist.



The original scientific methods were best described perhaps as inductivism and is a simplistic approach discussed by David Hume amonst others. It means if you observe an event and a cause/ occurence many times then a general statement of likelihood of cause can be set up and either described as true or false. As we will discover when we study issues with reasoning, inductive logic leads to mistakes in assumptions and the occurence of the fallacy of induction. (A fallacy means an unexpected mistake).

Falsification
is the usual and most respected idea about the scientific method. YOU MUST TRY TO REMEMBER THIS (!)idea. It was published by Karl Popper. It means in science you make an observation and suggest a theory. You then disprove all other possible explanations leaving your theory as the most trustworthy.

Paradigm
theory refers to a belief put forward by Kuhn, that scientists in reality are guided in their viewpoints and by underlying belief systems. They are unwitting slaves to their deep held beliefs and therefore cling to much to personal hypothesis and are ego driven in defence of their theories. This is an interesting idea when you consider why it took so long for theories such as evolution to be generally accepted, and perhaps why counter theories to global warming are dismissed very quickly by most.
Anarchist theory published by Paul Feyeraband and in this Feyeraband argues that actually most scientific discoveries have been down to chance and serendipity, that anything useful has been found by initial mistakes and subsequent sagacity to spot an opportunity.

Science, Baloney detection kit

Michael Shermer is the founder of the skeptics society and bases the ideas here and below upon original work by Carl Sagan, who now recently deceased was and still is one of the USA's most well known and globally respected scientists. In his book "the Demon Haunted world" he presents his baloney (meaning nonsense) detection kit. It is used by skeptics to find good science and to dismiss bad or psuedoscience. This clip below gives a good introduction. The kit is useful for us to help us establish knowledge that is trustworthy.



These ideas are useful for our discussion and the essay title: Art upsets; science reassures. Discuss.

You can see a written summary of these arguments here

Michael Shermer states further:
Clearly, there are no foolproof methods of detecting baloney or drawing the boundary between science and pseudoscience. Yet there is a solution: science deals in fuzzy fractions of certainties and uncertainties, where evolution and big bang cosmology may be assigned a 0.9 probability of being true, and creationism and UFOs a 0.1 probability of being true. In between are borderland claims: we might assign superstring theory a 0.7 and cryonics a 0.2. In all cases, we remain open-minded and flexible, willing to reconsider our assessments as new evidence arises. This is, undeniably, what makes science so fleeting and frustrating to many people; it is, at the same time, what makes science the most glorious product of the human mind.



The Author:
Michael Shermer is founding publisher of Skeptic magazine and author of
The Borderlands of Science.

Wednesday, 9 December 2009

Thursday, 3 December 2009

Tuesday, 1 December 2009

Emotional intelligence, Toondoo

Emotional Intelligence toon

Digital media, Toondoo

Here is the link for the fabulous toondoo.

Cartoon strip generator

Assignment help, Good TOK

Last week I was trying to give you advice on how to spot good TOK opportunities. These opportunities can be used in your TOK presentations or within your TOK essays due in January 14th (Chemists and Physicists), or 15th (Biologists). Where to begin?:

Firstly - finding inspiration. As your critical thinking skills develop you will begin to read about or follow on media such as youtube and ted.com more thought provoking material. Watch out for dogmatic statements people make (over confident in the self assuredness of the claim), watch out for so called conspiracy theories, pseudo-science and ethical disputes. My friend Nicola in her book "a new you" talks about all of us activating our "scooby ears" - it's that internal alarm going off - "how do they know that"?

Have a look at www.youtube.com and my "scooby ear" videos are stored under user: ultimatefrizbee - watch one or two and ask yourself - why is this here? How does it raise questions or challenge a certain viewpoint or paradigm? Then attempt to make the issue interesting.

Start reading broadsheet or alternative newspapers once a week. Try www.thefirstpost.co.uk remember whilst the articles here often challenge the consensus they are still open to further critical analysis by you.


Secondly. When you find a source/claim/issue that is intriguing,dogmatic or sounds spurious (lacking substance or truthfulness), work yourself your own angle of enquiry. Use the socratic method we have learnt. Ask the 4 wives and a husband type questions. Why, What,Who, Where and How?

Using my last post as an example:

Hollow Earth theory:

Example Good TOK questions:

Who is making such claims? Who else?
What is the theory challenging? What evidence do we need to get nearer to the truth claim behind this theory? What evidence can disprove or prove such a theory?

Where can I find counter-evidence, counter claims? Where is this theory being published? Where is the substatiated proof?

How can we know if the Earth is hollow? How can we ever know the full extent of the history of our planet? How satisfied should we be with our current understanding of our planet?

All these questions lead to more questions and therefore good TOK. However you still need to find some creativity yourself in how you present your questions, make them relevant, thought provoking and occassionally amusing. Why not? My hollow earth theory could mean ten years from now we are on an expedition inside the earth hunting Wooly Mammoths and Spacemen and wondering why we all found the theory stupid in 2009!